Sunday, November 22, 2026

Virginia Free Press

virginia free press

Politics

Side Issues Become Central to SCC Filing

The list of players involved in the Dominion-NextEra merger case before the SCC is long, and includes a list of asks likely set off by the two energy giants’ proffers. 

NextEra Dominion combined

Many of the associations, companies and activist groups filing official testimony last week on the proposed acquisition of Dominion Energy by NextEra Energy are raising issues unrelated to the basic application.

The narrow question before the three judges of the SCC is whether Dominion’s electricity consumers will continue to have reliable service at fair and reasonable rates under the larger combined entity. That is the standard set in Virginia law.

Dominion and NextEra themselves set off this focus on side issues with their own proffers of conditions including cash bill credits to customers, a pledge to maintain Virginia employment levels, and even a new office tower in downtown Richmond.  

The list of players seeking the SCC’s attention is the longest in any case in recent decades. 

Some witnesses filed confidential documents available only to case participants who have signed non-disclosure agreements.  Witnesses for the SCC staff filed public, “extraordinarily sensitive” and “confidential” testimony – three documents each.

The testimony can be found here, mixed in with other documents, motions and hundreds of public comments flowing in through the SCC’s comment portal.  That is how most elected officials are getting on the record, with simple comments.

Four local governments (Arlington, Fairfax, Alexandria and Charlottesville) have filed multiple affidavits focused on their fears over climate change and worries that the combination will imperil implementation of the Virginia Clean Economy Act (VCEA) and their local goals.  Alexandria’s Climate Action Officer testified the SCC must impose “climate commitments” if it approves the merger.  

As intervenors, these companies and groups have the right to participate in next month’s hearing, putting witnesses on the stand and cross-examining the company officials testifying.  If they sign the secrecy pledge, they can examine all the secret testimony from the company and from other witnesses and sit in closed hearings.     

Should there be a push to settle this case by negotiation, which often happens, they want to be in the room where that happens.  

Each testimony file includes, at the SCC’s direction, a one or perhaps two-page summary of the key points contained.  A quick review of those summaries indicates not one filed a full endorsement of Dominion and NextEra’s application.  Most either express strong opposition or state conditions they would require to make the deal acceptable.

The Virginia Poverty Law Center urges rejection, citing financial reasons and concerns about NextEra’s management history.  It then lists conditions related to the handling of overdue bills and cut-offs for nonpayment, recommends no late fees for residential customers, and seeks a shareholder funded program to erase debt to the utility. 

The municipal governments who provide local independent electricity systems dependent on purchased power from Dominion complain that the retail bill credits offered by NextEra will not extend to their 133,000 customers.  They also want additional protection against the utility passing along data center-related costs in the wholesale contracts.  

An official of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers asks the Commission to require that the companies use project labor agreements, union apprenticeships, and pay federal Davis-Bacon Act level wages on future construction jobs.  

Another labor coalition, the Mid-Atlantic Regional Organizing Coalition, conditions its support for the deal on the SCC enshrining both existing labor practices and a preference in future contracts for suppliers employing only union labor and union work rules.

The Corporate Energy Buyers Association represents large energy users strongly committed to “carbon emissions-free energy systems” and it wants the SCC to order NextEra to create a “clean customer tariff” focused on their freedom to provide power for themselves or purchase directly and to relieve them of some of the conditions imposed on the largest energy users. 

An association for private landlords owning apartments and office buildings complains that the original bill credits offered to its members by Dominion and NextEra were more lucrative than the second version of the bill credits and wants the initial offer to stay in place for them.   

Many of the intervenors did focus on the core financial issues raised by the proposal and possible restrictions the SCC could impose to insulate Dominion customers from risk. 

The environmental group Appalachian Voices filed 525 pages of testimony in combination with solar industry advocates focused on assumed financial risks to ratepayers under the proposal and not on environmental issues.  They retained the Massachusetts-based Brattle Group, which asserts that the larger combined entity would face less risk than before the merger and thus could earn unjust profits.  Sierra Club’s testimony also focused on financial risks to consumers but did mention VCEA.  

The giant retailer Walmart says the merger should be conditioned upon an expansion in its ability to offer electric vehicle charging at its stores.

Data and retailing megafirm Amazon wants the SCC to use this case to impose “a voluntary pathway under which any large-load customer meeting objective criteria may supply or fund new capacity to serve its own load and receive credit for it.”

All together, more than 25 different entities or coalitions filed official testimony with the SCC last week. They filed more than 50 documents, many running to hundreds of pages and at least one to almost 1,300 pages. Not one that was publicly available expressed unqualified support for the application. 

Previous reporting has mentioned that the SCC staff, Attorney General Jay Jones (D) and the independent market monitor for grid operator PJM Interconnection are all opposed to the acquisition by Florida-based NextEra.  Governor Abigail Spanberger (D) filed testimony focused on a long list of conditions that would win her support for the proposal.

Dominion and NextEra will file rebuttal testimony to challenge some of these witnesses, and which they choose to address may be an indication of which opponents are making the strongest points.  The hearing is set for November 17, and the SCC is required to decide the application by the middle of January.