Sunday, November 22, 2026

Virginia Free Press

virginia free press

Opinion

How did McGuire do it?

The Blue Tsunami vs. redistricting (and a Facebook Guy)

5th district

Since this is Virginia, we’re already on to the NEXT election. But forgive me if I want to take one last look at the 2026 results.

Obviously this was a historic election, with huge gains for the Democrats nationally. They won in typical battleground states, but also pulled off huge upsets in Republican strongholds like Kansas (!?) and Mississippi (!?!?!).

Here in Virginia, though, the victory felt… a little less overwhelming? Democrats did not perform as strongly as they did in other states. I’m especially hearing a lot of questions about what happened in the 5th Congressional District. Democrats had high hopes for Tom Perriello, but incumbent John McGuire managed to hold onto the seat.

In the year of the Blue Tsunami, with Democratic upset wins all over the country, how did McGuire hold on here in (blue) Virginia?

Too Many Republicans?

Dwayne Yancey of Cardinal News asked Virginia’s favorite pollster Chaz Nuttycombe the same question. Nuttycombe suggests that McGuire and national Republicans had woken up to the possibility of a Blue Tsunami in the waning days of the race, so they invested here to shore up his candidacy.

This makes some sense to my read of the arc of the election season. Early on, the toss-up race was seen as the 2nd, with Luria battling Kiggans in a mostly even race. Once it was clear that Luria was actually going to win handily, national attention turned to Wittman vs. Taylor and the 1st CD later in the year. But as we got closer to Election Day, both parties seemed to realize that Wittman was also likely toast. So they aimed their attention at the 5th as the next (and final) battleground.

I had a sense too that McGuire had not taken the race as seriously as he needed to until the end, so he had some money to spend in those last 2-3 weeks. I also had wondered if there would be bad blood among Republicans; recall that McGuire holds this seat due to a bruising primary challenge to then-incumbent Bob Good in 2024. Still, it seems like the district’s Republicans have forgiven McGuire, or at least enough to turn out to keep him in office.

Yancey also noted that the rural areas of the district – Campbell, Bedford, Pittsylvania counties – have, like many rural areas across the country, turned even more Republican. There are just too many Republicans in that district for even a Blue Tsunami to overcome.

The Perriello campaign knew this, of course. They had hoped to turn out Democrats in big numbers in urban/suburban centers like Danville, and especially Charlottesville and Albemarle County. And they especially hoped to turn out UVA students to run up a big margin in C’ville, with the state’s same-day registration rules helping to encourage students to get to the polls.

But as David Poole noted, there’s another big uni in this district: Liberty in Lynchburg, with a student body that’s just a wee more conservative. So any turnout advantage among UVA students was significantly blunted by turnout among their Liberty counterparts.


Still, there’s something else at work here. It wasn’t just the 5th district that didn’t match the overall vibe of the Blue Tsunami. The national popular vote swung about 15 points away from the Republicans from 2024 to 2026; in the competitive Virginia congressional races, that swing was much smaller, ranging from 7.5% in the 1st to a little over 10% in the 5th. What gives?

Virginia: Land of Elections

Some of this lesser swing might be explained by the national attention to these Virginia races from the get-go. Again, the national parties always saw the Virginia 2nd and 1st, as key battleground races, and Republicans invested a lot here to keep these Congressional races competitive. Plus there’s some local effects that may have changed the dynamics here, such as the noise about a former employee’s lawsuit against Taylor or the different perspectives on how Taylor handled a hospital child abuse case.

But there is one difference from other states that would matter across all Virginia elections: Virginia already had a Blue Wave election last year.

If we view this Blue Tsunami as a protest vote against Trump, voters in the Commonwealth already had a chance to lodge that vote last year. And they did, sending Abigail Spanberger into the Governor’s Mansion by a (there it is again) 15-point margin. It’s hard to know how this dynamic fits in with the kind of voter turnout we had this year, but maybe the squishy voters who turned out against Trump in other states felt like they’d already done their part here in Virginia?

Maybe that’s not a strong factor, but there is one thing that is also different as a result of last year’s elections: the Democrats, having won a trifecta last year, have had to actually govern this year. (“Winning was easy, young man; governing is harder.”) Early polls showed low approval ratings for the Governor (although those may have rebounded) and Democratic infighting over vetoes and the budget was widely reported. A sense that the Dems did not have a steady hand on the wheel might have contributed to a smaller swing this year than elsewhere.

I should mention that the three constitutional amendments on the ballot were supposed to contribute to Democratic turnout. But probably because the election was so dominated by national politics, the results were much more complicated than that, with some votes clearly crossing party lines.

Still, there’s one other election that may have played a role here, and one I’m not hearing much about. We had an election in April, remember?

The redistricting referendum, which was passed and then struck down by the Virginia Supreme Court, was supposed to create a 10-1 Congressional map that favored the Democrats, to counter gerrymandering efforts in other states. That battle dominated Virginia politics earlier this year. And then it went away. Only, maybe it didn’t? Is it possible that while the Democrats moved on to make the case against Trump and his Republican cronies in Congress, Virginia Republicans remembered what they saw as a Democratic power grab that would disenfranchise them for years?

How much did rural voters in Bedford or Amherst remember April when they went to the polls this November? Could their anger over gerrymandering have factored into their motivation to keep at least one Republican in office?

Spoiler Alert

If you look at the final numbers, there’s one more reason that Perriello lost his race, a reason that Mark Warner’s campaign manager may have mentioned in VPAP’s annual “After Virginia Votes” event this week.

There was an independent who also ran in the 5th: Cooke Harvey, a construction worker from Amherst County. Harvey received just shy of 6,000 votes – less than 2%. That’s about 250 more votes than McGuire’s margin of victory.

Harvey’s campaign was quixotic, to say the least. He refused donations, and campaigned mostly though a series of daily Facebook videos. It’s not clear who actually voted for him – disaffected, anti-Trump Republicans? Lefties opposed to moderate Democratic politics? True independents who want an alternative to the two parties? We certainly can’t just assign all of his voters to Perriello, so I don’t think Harvey shoulders the blame here for a Democratic loss. Still, it can’t have helped.

The bottom line here is that McGuire and the Republicans deserve some credit for salvaging a victory in a tough year for their party overall. Still, I don’t know that there are any lessons to be learned from that victory, either for the state or national party. In many ways, based on demographics alone, McGuire always should have won. If the Republicans can’t sort out their national party leadership, and victories like McGuire’s still feel like they need explanation, that’s a big problem to have.


RICH MEAGHER is a professor, analyst, and podcast host who knows all things Virginia politics. (Well, most things.)