Friday, November 20, 2026

Virginia Free Press

virginia free press

Albemarle County Schools in Crisis: A Timeline

Updated Nov. 20, 2026. This timeline will be updated as events unfold.

Registry checks cleared

337 of 524 employees

As of Nov. 20, according to ACPS. All 337 came back with no findings of child abuse or neglect. 187 are still waiting on the state Department of Social Services. Source: ACPS

Editor’s note: On Wednesday afternoon, the acting superintendent of Albemarle County Public Schools (ACPS) told families that the division would close beginning Thursday, November 19, and remain closed through at least Thanksgiving break, after discovering that more than 500 employees hired in the previous three years had never been checked against the state’s Child Protective Services Central Registry.

The closure is the latest turn in a series of events that began in January 2026, when an employee was placed on leave. A grand jury indicted him June 1 on 11 felony counts, including aggravated sexual battery and indecent liberties, and added nine more charges in October. Since January, another staff member has been arrested on child sex charges, the superintendent has been forced to resign, three School Board members have resigned, three administrators have been charged with failing to report suspected abuse, and a $5 million lawsuit is pending.

The Virginia Free Press compiled this timeline from news reports beginning in mid-2025. It also includes a Who’s Who of key people and a list of key dates ahead.

Did we miss something? If you find an error, or have information or tips about this story, please contact Martin Davis at mdavis@virginiafreepress.com. We will correct or update this timeline.

Two different checks

New ACPS employees go through two separate screenings. The first is a fingerprint-based criminal background check through the Virginia State Police. The second is a search of the Virginia Department of Social Services’ Child Protective Services Central Registry, which lists people with findings of child abuse or neglect.

According to ACPS, the 524 employees passed the criminal check. Their information was never submitted for the registry check. Hayes said none of the employees now under investigation are among the 524.


Timeline

Entries run oldest to newest so the story reads in order. Charges are allegations; no one named below except Nicholas Clark has been convicted.

Background: 2025

June 12, 2025

The School Board votes to increase its members’ annual pay from $7,915 to $16,249. Source: Crozet Gazette

June 13, 2025

The School Board extends Superintendent Matthew Haas’s contract to June 30, 2028, with a 3 percent raise. Source: Crozet Gazette

Nov. 4, 2025

Jim Dillenbeck unseats appointed Rio District School Board member Leslie Pryor with about 51% of the vote. Source: Cville Right Now

Part 1: The arrests (January–June 2026)

Jan. 8

Dillenbeck and Bob Beard are sworn in as new School Board members. Rebecca Berlin is elected chair and Allison Spillman vice chair. Source: ACPS

January

A student reports inappropriate sexual contact by a Hollymead staff member, and police open an investigation. ACPS says it put Michael Swiney on leave and notified police and Child Protective Services (CPS). Superintendent Matthew Haas does not inform the School Board. Sources: Charlottesville Tomorrow, Cville Right Now

March 2

Woodbrook Elementary fifth-grade teacher Nicholas Clark is arrested on child pornography charges. Haas sends a message to parents informing them of the arrest. The message is inadvertently sent to “all ACPS students in grades 6 through 12.” Haas sends a second email saying he was “sorry for this mistake.” Sources: Augusta Free Press, ACPD arrest announcement

April 20

ACPS launches a Title IX awareness campaign. Source: ACPS announcement

June 1

A grand jury indicts Swiney on 11 felony counts, including aggravated sexual battery and indecent liberties. Source: Charlottesville Tomorrow

June 3–4

The board first learns of the investigation on June 3. Swiney turns himself in, and police announce the arrest June 4, which is how many families find out. Sources: Cville Right Now, C-Ville Weekly

June 10

At a tense Hollymead meeting, Haas says police told him not to notify families. “At no point in the investigation did ACPD instruct ACPS that they could not notify internal stakeholders,” ACPD spokesperson Logan Bogert told Cville Right Now. “As a general practice, when law enforcement is conducting an active criminal investigation, individuals with knowledge of the investigation may be asked to not publicly disclose information that could compromise investigative efforts and/or the privacy of victims involved.” Bogert said “internal stakeholders” would include the division’s leadership, but not teachers or families. Source: Cville Right Now

June 11

The School Board asks Haas to resign. Source: WDBJ7/29News

June 13

Hollymead Principal Joe McCauley goes on administrative leave. Source: Cville Right Now

June 17

Assistant Superintendent Chandra Hayes is named acting superintendent for the 2026–27 school year. Source: Cville Right Now

June 18

ACPS opens a Family Assistance Center at Journey Middle School with the Victims Crisis Assistance and Response Team (VCART), Region Ten, and other community partners, offering support to families, students, staff, and community members affected by the charges against an ACPS employee. Source: ACPS statement

June 20

Haas’s exit terms are announced: regular pay and benefits through June 2027. Source: Cville Right Now

Part 2: Pressure builds (July–September 2026)

July 2

Hayes tells parents the unlicensed social emotional learning coach role will end at Hollymead and be phased out divisionwide. Source: Charlottesville Tomorrow

July 9

McCauley resigns as principal of Hollymead. Source: Cville Right Now

Rep. John McGuire (R-5th District) sends a letter asking Gov. Abigail Spanberger and Attorney General Jay Jones to launch an independent investigation of ACPS. Source: Cville Right Now

July 16

The board adopts a Professional Boundaries policy limiting one-on-one staff meetings with students. Read the Professional Boundaries and Prevention of Sexual Misconduct and Abuse policy. Sources: Crozet Gazette, Cville Right Now

July 17

Assistant Superintendent Patrick McLaughlin goes on paid leave after harassment allegations are aired at a board meeting by Heidi Gilman Bennett, a family counseling officer with ACPS. That same day, three state legislators send a letter seeking an independent investigation about the issues in the school division. Sources: WDBJ7/29News, WSET

State Sen. Creigh Deeds and Dels. Katrina Callsen and Amy Laufer, all Democrats, send the School Board a letter urging it to consider an independent investigation. Source: WHSV

Aug. 4

Vice Chair Allison Spillman announces her resignation (last meeting Aug. 13). The board votes 7–0 to hire Harman Claytor Corrigan & Wellman for an independent review; parents object that the firm has represented the board before. Sources: Charlottesville Tomorrow, 29News, ACPS

Aug. 13

The Albemarle Circuit Court orders Swiney held without bail. At the hearing, prosecutors allege he sexually abused four girls under 13 between August 2024 and January 2026, and Chief Deputy Commonwealth’s Attorney Lawton Tufts questions the division’s trustworthiness and its handling of Title IX reports about Swiney. Source: C-Ville Weekly

Aug. 17

Board Chair Rebecca Berlin sends a letter to Commonwealth’s Attorney James Hingeley challenging assertions made during a bond hearing for Swiney that “the division failed to meet its mandatory reporting obligation.” Source: Read the letter from Berlin to Hingeley

Aug. 27

Clark pleads guilty to five felony counts of possessing child pornography. Sentencing is set for Dec. 2. Source: Cville Right Now

Sept. 25

Supervisor Sally Duncan calls for an independent investigation. Source: Charlottesville Community Engagement

Sept. 28

Three principals are reported out of their buildings for an “extended period.” They return to their schools Nov. 17. Sources: Charlottesville Community Engagement, Cville Right Now

Sept. 30

At a town hall, Dillenbeck says the division is in “crisis” and that 15 employees were placed on leave in the prior 30 days. Sources: Daily Progress, Charlottesville Community Engagement

Part 3: Charges, a resignation, and outside intervention (October 2026)

Oct. 6

A grand jury adds charges from three more victims. Swiney now faces 20 felony counts involving at least seven alleged victims. Sources: Charlottesville Community Engagement, WHRO/WMRA

Oct. 7

Dillenbeck resigns at the request of the other five members, who say he disclosed confidential personnel information and presented rumor as fact. Sources: Cville Right Now, 29News, Daily Progress

The same day, police announce that former Hollymead principal Joseph McCauley, Deputy Chief HR Officer Brodie Downs, and Title IX Coordinator Erin Stone were indicted and arrested. Each faces three misdemeanor counts of failing to report suspected child abuse. Sources: Charlottesville Community Engagement, 12 On Your Side

Oct. 8

David Storm is sworn in to fill Spillman’s at-large seat. Source: Charlottesville Community Engagement

Oct. 15

The Board of Supervisors unanimously asks the School Board for transparency and asks the state Department of Education to review the division. Sources: C-Ville Weekly, Cville Right Now

Oct. 19

WMRA Public Radio airs a story that includes interviews with Albemarle teachers about the number of employees being placed on leave. Source: Read or listen to the story

Oct. 22

The School Board directs Hayes to draft a 30-60-90-day plan and create a Compliance and Constituent Services Office. Source: 29News

ACPS spokesperson Jason Grant says the division named Jessica Cochran interim Title IX coordinator the previous week, replacing Stone in that role. Stone remains employed as assistant school division counsel. Source: Cville Right Now

Oct. 27

State Superintendent Jenna Conway orders ACPS to hire a new independent consultant within 10 business days, under state oversight. VDOE will choose one if the division does not. Sources: C-Ville Weekly, 29News, Charlottesville Tomorrow

Oct. 29

A federal lawsuit seeking at least $5 million alleges ACPS mishandled a separate student-on-student sexual assault report. It names the board, Stone, and Chief Legal Officer Josiah Black as defendants. Source: 12 On Your Side

Part 4: The closure (November 2026)

Nov. 4

ACPS spokesperson Jason Grant confirms that Chief Legal Officer Josiah Black is on leave, less than a week after he was named in the federal lawsuit. Grant does not give a reason. Source: Cville Right Now

Nov. 6

In an open letter to the School Board published by the Crozet Gazette, Dillenbeck writes that the division is “in crisis” and lists problems he says the board needs to address. Among them: staff vacancies he ties to the disciplinary and leave process, grading practices, a stalled committee on the achievement gap, an overdue strategic plan, aging buildings, teacher workload and testing, a shortage of bus drivers, and central office spending. He puts that spending at roughly $20 million in salaries and benefits for about 120 staff. He urges members to listen to teachers, administrators, and parents. Source: Crozet Gazette

Nov. 12

The board appoints Leslie Pryor to the vacant Rio seat on a 5–1 vote. Pryor had served on the board before losing the seat to Dillenbeck the previous November. Hayes presents an improvement plan. Read the plan. Sources: Cville Right Now, 29News

The board also votes 6–0 to approve a compliance plan expected to cost about $515,000 this fiscal year: $240,000 for an organizational study that includes the state-ordered review, $200,000 for a new compliance office, and $75,000 for help with public records requests and outside communications. An interim report from the review is expected in February and a final report in April. Source: The Center Square

Nov. 13

Vice Chair Ellen Osborne resigns, effective Dec. 1, citing a family matter. She is the third member to leave this year. A petition to remove Kate Acuff is circulating. Sources: Cville Right Now, 29News

Nov. 17

The three principals removed from their schools in September “for an extended time” are back in their roles. Source: Cville Right Now

Nov. 18

Shortly after 3 p.m., ACPS announces all schools will close starting Nov. 19 over the missed CPS registry checks. The board holds a special meeting that night for legal advice. Chief Legal Officer Josiah Black, on leave since early November, joins the board and Hayes in the closed session. Sources: Charlottesville Tomorrow, WRIC, Cville Right Now

That evening, Gov. Abigail Spanberger releases a statement saying the division’s prior leadership “failed the children and families they serve” by not conducting legally required background checks. Superintendent of Public Instruction Jenna Conway says ACPS reported the issue to the state Department of Education on Monday, Nov. 16. Sources: CBS19, NBC News

Nov. 19

Schools are closed. Hayes says she decided after consulting the state social services and education departments, and that the problem surfaced in a review she began after taking over. Source: Cville Right Now

The 524 are all current employees, including bus drivers, office assistants, teachers, and teaching assistants, with no pattern by position, Hayes says. She says the human resources department sometimes processed the registry paperwork and sometimes did not, and the unsubmitted forms date from 2023 to 2026. All 524 files were hand-delivered to the Virginia Department of Social Services in Richmond at 12:03 p.m. on Nov. 18. Source: 29News

The Albemarle Education Association, which represents ACPS teachers and staff, backs Hayes’s decision to close schools until every check is complete, calling it “the cautious call,” but says the situation “should never have happened.” Source: Cville Right Now

Rep. John McGuire (R-5th District) calls for state and federal authorities, including the FBI, to investigate ACPS over the missed registry checks. Source: 29News

In an update to families that evening, Hayes says the Virginia Department of Social Services has processed 186 of the 524 employees who need to be screened, and all 186 came back clear, with no findings of child abuse or neglect. The division will post a running count on its website and is working toward reopening Monday, Nov. 30. Free meals are offered Nov. 20 in every school cafeteria, with take-home breakfast and lunch for Nov. 23 and 24. Sources: 29News, ACPS

Nov. 20

ACPS says the state has now screened 337 of the 524 employees, with no findings of child abuse or neglect. Source: ACPS

Hayes says the employees responsible for onboarding have been identified and that the division has taken “swift action” under its protocols. She does not say what that action is. Source: Cville Right Now

Just under two dozen parents, teachers, and staff gather outside the Albemarle County Office Building. Board member Bob Beard says he is “outraged, and upset, and angry” but supports the closure. Some attendees, including Albemarle Republican Committee Chairman Phil Riese, call for those responsible to be fired. Source: Cville Right Now

State Sen. Creigh Deeds and Dels. Katrina Callsen and Amy Laufer release a joint statement on the closure. They say they have been in contact with state agencies, the governor’s office, the Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office, School Board representatives, and affected families. They pledge to introduce legislation in the coming General Assembly session to require parental notification, close licensing gaps that could let unsafe staff move to other jobs, and limit nondisclosure agreements with families and students. Read the letter. Sources: CBS19, 29News


Three School Board departures

The three departures were not alike. Spillman and Osborne gave personal reasons. Dillenbeck was asked to leave by his colleagues.

MemberSeatAnnouncedStated reasonReplacement
Allison SpillmanAt-largeAug. 4Had weighed leaving for months; said it was not a response to calls for the board to resignDavid Storm, sworn in Oct. 8
Jim DillenbeckRio DistrictOct. 7Asked to resign by the other five members over alleged disclosure of confidential informationLeslie Pryor, appointed Nov. 12
Ellen OsborneScottsville DistrictNov. 13A family matter; resignation effective Dec. 1To be appointed; seat on the November 2027 ballot

What to watch next

  • By Nov. 27: ACPS says it will confirm whether schools reopen Nov. 30, once the state social services department clears the backlog of registry checks.
  • Dec. 1: Osborne’s resignation takes effect, leaving a second vacancy to fill by appointment. Her Scottsville seat is on the November 2027 ballot.
  • Dec. 2: Clark is scheduled to be sentenced.
  • Dec. 10: Hayes is scheduled to give the board her first public progress report on the compliance plan.
  • February and April: Interim and final reports from the state-ordered review are expected.
  • The state-ordered review: Hayes brought on the consultant for the state-ordered review Nov. 18, but the firm has not been named publicly. It is unclear what becomes of the Harman Claytor review.
  • Court dates for Swiney and for McCauley, Downs, and Stone, plus the federal lawsuit.
  • The superintendent search and the petition to remove Acuff.

Who’s who

PersonRoleWhere they stand now
Chandra HayesActing superintendent since June 2026Ordered the Nov. 19 closure
Matthew HaasSuperintendent, 2018 to June 2026Resigned at the board’s request; paid through June 2027
Rebecca BerlinSchool Board chair (White Hall District)Leading the board’s response and town halls
Ellen OsborneSchool Board vice chair (Scottsville District)Resigned, effective Dec. 1
Jim DillenbeckSchool Board member (Rio District), January to October 2026Resigned Oct. 7 at the other members’ request
Allison SpillmanSchool Board member (at-large) and former vice chairResigned in August
Kate AcuffSchool Board member (Jack Jouett District)Target of a removal petition
David Storm and Leslie PryorAppointed School Board members (at-large; Rio District)Seated Oct. 8 and Nov. 12
Michael SwineyFormer Hollymead Elementary social emotional learning coachFaces 20 felony counts; has said he denies the allegations
Nicholas ClarkFormer Woodbrook Elementary teacherPleaded guilty Aug. 27 to five child pornography counts; sentencing Dec. 2
Joe McCauleyFormer Hollymead Elementary principalCharged with failing to report suspected child abuse
Brodie DownsDeputy chief human resources officerCharged with failing to report suspected child abuse
Erin StoneAssistant division counsel and Title IX coordinatorCharged with failing to report suspected child abuse
Josiah BlackChief legal officerOn leave; not charged
Jenna ConwayVirginia superintendent of public instructionOrdered a state-supervised review Oct. 27

How this was compiled: The Virginia Free Press used both Claude and ChatGPT to make a first sweep of news stories and create an outline of events. The VFP team then conducted an independent search for additional news stories related to these events. The findings were compiled into a master document, and each story and date was verified by our editorial team.